Uncovering the Challenges & Opportunities for Customer Loyalty Programs Through Data

Toju Ometoruwa · August 8, 2023
Uncovering the Challenges & Opportunities for Customer Loyalty Programs Through Data

Today, brands face numerous challenges in delivering successful customer loyalty programs. From keeping customers engaged and maintaining their interest, to retaining them in a fiercely competitive marketplace, and from measuring program effectiveness to preventing fraudulent activities, the path is paved with hurdles. 

However, with the rise of Web3 technologies, businesses can revolutionize their approach to customer loyalty programs, crafting more personalized, secure, and effective strategies that resonate with modern customers. This in turn allows them to realize the benefits of a highly engaged customer base. Successfully engaged customers represent an average 23% premium in terms of share of profitability, revenue, and relationship growth compared to less engaged ones.

#Amplifying Customer Retention with Web3 

In today's competitive business landscape, a significant number of companies, approximately 44%, prioritize customer acquisition over retention. However, only 18% focus on nurturing their existing customer base. This approach often overlooks the fact that retaining a loyal customer can be more cost-effective and profitable than acquiring a new one. In this context, Web3 technologies emerge as a game-changer, offering innovative solutions to enhance customer retention strategies.

Web3 technologies, particularly blockchain, bring a unique proposition to the table - the concept of true ownership. This is especially relevant in the context of loyalty programs. Traditionally, loyalty points are confined within the ecosystem of the issuing brand and can only be redeemed as per the brand's policies. However, with Web3, customers can have true ownership of their loyalty points, which are often tokenized and stored in their digital wallets.

This true ownership extends to the ability to transfer, trade, or even sell these loyalty points. For instance, a customer could earn loyalty tokens from a coffee shop, and then trade them with a friend for tokens from a bookstore. This level of flexibility and control is unprecedented in traditional loyalty programs and makes the program more attractive to customers.

Consider the example of Starbucks, a company that has been at the forefront of leveraging Web3 technologies for its loyalty program. Starbucks has been exploring the use of blockchain to create a more customer-centric rewards program. By tokenizing rewards, customers can potentially trade their Starbucks tokens for other tokens or even sell them, providing a level of flexibility and ownership that is not possible with traditional loyalty programs.

Another example is Nike, which has been experimenting with token-based loyalty programs. Nike token holders could potentially use their tokens to get early access to new products, unique customization options, or even exclusive events. This not only incentivizes customers to stay engaged with the brand but also creates a sense of community and loyalty among token holders.

The impact of these enhanced loyalty programs on customer retention can be significant. According to research by Bain & Company, increasing customer retention rates by just 5% can increase profits by 25% to 95%. This is because repeat customers are more likely to purchase from a brand they trust and are often more willing to try new products.

#Elevating Program Effectiveness through Web3

Measuring the effectiveness of a loyalty program is a multifaceted task, requiring the tracking of key metrics such as customer churn rate, customer lifetime value (CLV), and the redemption rate of loyalty points. Web3 technologies can significantly enhance the measurement of program effectiveness. By providing a transparent and verifiable record of all transactions and wallet addresses. Web3 simplifies the tracking of these crucial metrics. For instance, Scotch & Soda, a prominent clothing brand, uses Web3 technologies in its loyalty program to monitor customer behavior and tailor offerings, setting a new standard for retail business to measure the impact of their programs by tracking members’ wallet addresses.  Doing so allows them to assess how many NFTs a member has collected and how often they redeem these NFTs to access exclusive experiences, events and offers.

#Harnessing Untapped Consumer Demand through Token Loyalty Programs

According to recent studies, around 69% of customer loyalty programs have been successful in influencing customer decisions, with members of these programs generating an impressive 12-18% more incremental revenue growth per year than non-members. Moreover, research suggests that higher engagement loyalty program members spend 25% more than dormant members. 

These statistics underscores the potential of harnessing untapped consumer demand through Web3 technologies. For example, Mattel, a global leader in the toy industry, has implemented a token-based loyalty program to  encourage active engagement by offering unique rewards and experiences to token holders, thereby increasing their spending and boosting the program's effectiveness. Mattel was able to generate $750K in sales in less than 12 hours by selling NFTs of their popular Barbie and Hot Wheels toy collections on their own peer-to-peer marketplace. 

#Fraud Prevention: The Web3 Way Explored

Fraud prevention is another critical aspect of running a successful loyalty program. With loyalty program fraud having risen by a staggering 89% in recent years and 17.6% of respondents stating that loyalty fraud grew significantly in the last three years, businesses must seek innovative solutions to safeguard their loyalty programs.

Brands are finding it hard to strike a balance between security and customer experience, with 42% citing this as their top challenge in 2023. Increasingly, companies must confront the costs of fake accounts, unauthorized takeovers, and misinformation, jeopardizing data integrity, system security, and trust. Sophisticated security protocols often create more hurdles for users when creating or logging into accounts, leading to frustration. Brands recognize the importance of customer protection, but revenue remains paramount. 

Web3 technologies prove their worth in this regard. By using blockchain, Web3 enhances the security of loyalty programs and helps prevent fraudulent activities such as point hacking and account takeover. For instance, blockchain's immutable and transparent nature makes it nearly impossible for hackers to manipulate the system and steal loyalty points.

Moreover, the use of smart contracts in Web3 loyalty programs can automate the process of points allocation and redemption, reducing the risk of human error and fraudulent manipulation. For example, Salesforce Web3 has integrated smart contract templates into its CRM tool, allowing for greater customization and security for their NFT programs.

This not only maintains the integrity of the program but also significantly mitigates the risk of financial losses. By ensuring the security and trustworthiness of their loyalty programs, businesses can enhance customer confidence and loyalty, further boosting the effectiveness of their programs.

Ultimately, Web3 technologies offer innovative solutions to elevate the effectiveness and security of loyalty programs. By harnessing the power of Web3, businesses can gain deeper insights into customer behavior, improve program effectiveness, and ensure robust fraud prevention, thereby fostering stronger customer relationships and driving business growth.


As we move forward, the adoption of Web3 technologies in loyalty programs appears more of a necessity than a choice. With the power to enhance customer engagement, retention, program effectiveness, and fraud prevention, Web3 holds the key to shaping a new era of customer loyalty. In an age where the average consumer is enrolled in 18 loyalty programs but actively engages with less than half, leveraging Web3 technology can truly transform the landscape of customer loyalty programs. ⁠ ⁠Subscribe for More Web3 Insights to Boost Your Customer Engagement.

Let's make some magic!